Google
Custom Search

Monday, March 03, 2008

So THAT'S why the Council of Europe thinks intelligent design theory is a threat to human rights!

Recently, I was interviewed by a fellow journalist who wanted me to explain why the Council of Europe thought that intelligent design theory was a threat to human rights. I said quite honestly I hadn't a clue. If they are post-modernists, their views can be fact-free. The relevant question might be "What do you guys smoke these days?"

Finally, this morning, I stumbled on an answer that at least moves the Council of Europe from the realm of toxic smoke to the realm of coherence. They're still wrong, certainly as far as North America is concerned, but at least they are now making sense. Here's a short trail of correspondence that explains it:

Thomas K. Johnson, Academic Dean, Baltic Reformed Seminary: Riga and Vilnius*, writes to explain a problem that has come up:
In Europe we face the problem that some Muslims borrow ID argumentation for their educational literature, then argue:

1. Allah is the Designer of all;

2. therefore all people must submit to Allah;

3. therefore the Sharia must be imposed on all people, regardless of religion or culture;

4. therefore it is properly to persecute (even kill) those who do not submit to the Intelligent Designer and his law, the Sharia.

Like it or not, ID argumentation is being used by some Muslims as part of their explanation of why it is right to wage jihad against secularists, Christians, and Jews.


I wrote back, offering,
Thanks much for info, Thomas! Is that how the Council of Europe got round to declaring ID a threat to human rights?

If so, the C of E's concern is still a crock because the 4-part argument you report ASSUMES the existence of a theocratic state/superstate (which Europe supposedly isn't).

Even if points 1 and 2 are conceded to be true, points 3 and 4 don't follow from them.

That is, if God exists and people ignore him, they will certainly have trouble, but their neighbours need not persecute them in order to bring it about the trouble. It is a natural effect, and shows much more clearly when it is left to be a natural effect.

For example, in The Spiritual Brain, Mario Beauregard and I show that, in most studies done in North America, spiritually minded people have better physical and mental health than others.

No human government causes this effect or prevents it. The effect arises from a true interpretation of the nature of our universe.

If the government started forcing people to go to church, the effect would apparently disappear because many unhappy, unconvinced people would be sitting angrily in churches ...

The effect – which is a powerful argument for God - can only be observed when there is no compulsion in religion.


He wrote back and didn't dispute that, but noted,
There is no danger of a theocracy in Europe any time soon, even though some of our Muslim neighbors openly proclaim their desire to turn the secular European Union into the Islamic Republic of Europe under sharia law. The Muslims simply do not have enough people in Europe to make that a reality right now; their numbers are still below 10% of the population of the entire Continent. But their pronouncements have irked enough people that the Council of Europe declared ID a threat to Human Rights and the future of science.

Much of the world does not simply assume freedom of religion in the sense you (and I) probably accept. Many people assume that if their religion is true, then it is the duty of their government to promote their true religion.

Muslim notions of theocracy are rooted in the notion of Allah being the Creator/Designer of all. Their logic is, he created all, therefore he must rule all, therefore sharia law for all people and all sectors of life. Notions of design and creation normally have pushed Jews and Christians towards democracy, whereas Muslim notions of design and creation normally push them towards theocracy.


Dr. Johnson gave me permission to publish this correspondence, and it certainly provides food for thought. In North America, most people who think that the universe shows evidence of design assume that religious freedom is essential because, with religious freedom, people will discover the evidence for God themselves, as ex-atheist Antony Flew famously did.

Come to think of it, most North Americans do believe in God, and in science, and in religious freedom. Not an accident, I think.

*He is apparently also Vice President for Research and Personnel Development
Martin Bucer Seminary: Bonn, Berlin, Istanbul, Hamburg, Zurich, Innsbruck, Ankara, Zlin, Chemnitz, Pforzheim;
Director, Comenius Institute: Prague
Fellow, International Institute for Christian Studies

Updated march 12 2008:

My friend Turkish journalist Mustafa Akyol writes,

[Quoting Thomas K, Johnson:]"Muslim notions of theocracy are rooted in the notion of Allah being the Creator/Designer of all. Their logic is, he created all, therefore he must rule all, therefore sharia law for all people and all sectors of life. Notions of design and creation normally have pushed Jews and Christians towards democracy, whereas Muslim notions of design and creation normally push them towards theocracy."

Well, not necessarily. Actually all Muslims believe in creation (thus a "Designer"), but quite many of them support democracy. The Muslim case for democracy, in a nutshell, is this: God is all-knowing, but since no human being (except the prophets) can claim to speak for Him, there is no divinely ordained authority. We must consult with each other while managing our affairs, because God gave all of us intelligence...

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, October 17, 2007

American mathematician living in Paris on Europe’s anti-ID resolution ...

Here’s a podcast of mathematician and novelist David Berlinski, who lives in Paris, on the Council of Europe’s decision to ban the teaching of ID or creationism from the classroom. Berlinski’s own views of intelligent design are somewhat nuanced, as these self-interviews show, though his view of the Darwinist shock troops is not:
entirely low-market; the men who contribute to the blog all have some vague technical background - computer sales, sound mixing, low-level programming, print-shops or copy centers; they are semi-literate; their posts convey that characteristic combination of pustules and gonorrhea that one would otherwise associate with high-school toughs.


And here are links to some of his beautifully written essays.

Labels: ,

Saturday, October 06, 2007

Council of Europe resolution against teaching "creationism" sure to spike ID in Europe

Several European friends have asked me what I think about the Council of Europe's resolution against teaching ID and/or creationism. Alas, I won't be able to blog on this in any detail for a couple of days, but here are a couple of thoughts:

1. Have a look at Intelligent design controversy timeline An ID Timeline: In North America, the ID folk seem always to win when they lose.

There is a very simple, obvious reason: Most folk are not interested in how the universe, life, or the mind arose UNTIL you tell them that they are not allowed to discuss intelligence or design. Resolutions like the one above are a gift to the ID guys. Already, the troops are rallying, and more conferences like this one are surely under way.

2. This move may have been aimed against Europe's residual Christians and surging Muslims, but it won't affect only them. Ulrich Mohrhoff, a New Ager, is just as upset.

3. I have ordered a copy of Harun Yahya's Atlas of Creation, which (some say) has got the Council's shirts in a knot, and will tell you what I think after I have read it.

Well, the way things are going, I sure won't have to go back to the trade mag beat any time soon.

Also, new at THe Mindful Hack, Scientific American looks respectuflly at the work of my lead author on The Spiritual Brain Mario Beauregard

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, June 26, 2007

George Orwell would be proud of the Council of Europe - "I predicted it!"

I gather that the move by the Council of Europe to portray intelligent design theory as a threat to human rights has been put off - for now.

A number of things could be said about the Council of Europe’s move. First that you can be sure that the Council will be back later. Second, no matter what they get, they will want more. They can't help that. Materialism is failing and there are ever more "enemies" to suppress.


Third, that the Council twists the definition of “human rights” into something straight out of British political journalist George Orwell’s urgent mid-twentieth century warnings: Human rights means being protected by the State from anyone who might challenge your thinking.

For those who would like to get up to speed on Orwell (1903-1950), whose pen name* gave the English language the term “Orwellian”, go here for his essay, “Politics and the English Language” (1946), here for a synopsis of his futurist novel Nineteen Eighty Four , and here for a synopsis of his sendup of creeping socialist totalitarianism, Animal Farm . Unlike modern Darwinists, Orwell could predict, not just postdict.

(*Note: Orwell’s name was Eric Blair.)

I think Orwell made only one important error in his key ideas: He assumed that the face of the totalitarianism that he sensed growing up around him would be hard and cold. Aldous Huxley knew better. In Brave New World (synopsis here ) he gets Europe dead right - soft totalitarianism rules. People are protected from any reason to doubt or question the authorities’ beliefs, for their own alleged good. They are, indeed, free to do absolutely anything they want, except think, speak, or act for themselves.

Recently, I was having coffee with a Christian academic who professed concern about the rapid growth of this type of intolerance. As he meets with other Christian academics to share concerns, I offered him some guidelines for dealing with it, which I have presented here in a slightly adapted form. Please note that the material that follows is aimed at Christians, not because they are the only ones concerned but because they are frequent current targets, and I know the Christian community better than others:

1. Quit feeling guilty. This is not happening because of something we did.

Lord knows,
you're no rose,
but that's not why they hate you.


The secularist establishment hates the Christians who are most successful and commendable the most. Hitchens wrote a book against Mother Theresa, not against Jim Bakker.

2. Quit making scapegoats. It is not happening because other Christians are stupider or wickeder than us. The secularists' hatred is not our fellow Christians' fault any more than it is ours. When one target fails them, they simply find another one.

3. It is not happening because the people who tried to help made a mess of things. The people who actually try to help face a very difficult battle, and mistakes and losses are inevitable - except for those who do little or nothing. THEY can always be right, of course, but never
commendable.

4. Quit hiding the fact that we are Christians. It is actually safer to just admit it, because openness on our part makes covert persecution more difficult.*

5. Learn as much as we can about intelligent design; the materialists wouldn't hate it so much if it were not a threat to their system.

6. Focus on getting the people we are trying to organize to accept the hatred and the political situation it creates as simple realities. Quickly shut down discussions about who is to blame other than the persecutor and the bigot. Such discussions are evasions. (Yes, it is true that some people should behave differently, but if we can't persuade them, we must deal with the situation just as it is, kvetching is a waste of time, and things will only deteriorate if we do nothing.)

Now, the above list is not a series of action points for getting anything done. It is a baseline for real-world discussions, aimed at short circuiting the purveyors of comfy intellectual clutter. (Make no mistake: Some people are quite happy to justify inaction against substantial erosions of intellectual freedom by claiming that it is all some fellow Christian's fault.) Once real-world discussions about classical intellectual freedom begin, many people will come forward with ideas with discussing.

Speaking of clutter, many serious Christians are due for great disappointment with the responses of their comfy academics and their "therapeutic culture" clergy to the growing oppression by materialists. Of course, assuming they read the Bible as often as they read celeb trash talk - Christian or otherwise - that should be no surprise to them. Judgement begins, after all, with the house of God.

Labels: , ,

Who links to me?